Robinson lettered three years in football, '82, '83, and '84. A two-year starter for the Raiders, he recorded 86 tackles and three interceptions, including two during his stellar senior season. Robinson played on two Division I-AA playoff teams at Colgate before moving on to have a 16-year professional career in the National Football League (NFL). He played 11 seasons (1985-95) for the Seattle Seahawks, where he was twice named to the Pro Bowl (1992, 993). Robinson also earned the prestigious Seattle Man of the Year award in 1991, 1992, and 1995. After the 1995 season, Robinson continued his success in Green Bay, where he helped lead the Packers to back-to-back Super Bowls and a championship in 1996. He made his third straight Super Bowl with the Atlanta Falcons in 1998 before finishing his NFL career in 2000 with the Carolina Panthers. In 16 seasons, Robinson made 1,415 tackles, 57 interceptions and 22 fumble recoveries. His 16-year NFL career is the longest professional tenure in program history. 

McKenzie was one of the most decorated volleyball players in school history, highlighted by her appearance three times on the All-Patriot League First Team. She finished her career as Colgate's career kill leader (1,461), solo block leader (144) and block assist leader (371). In her senior season, she was named AVCA District 1 Division I First Team, the Patriot League's Offensive Player of the Year and Patriot League Tournament MVP while leading the Raiders to their first-ever appearance in the NCAA tournament. As a junior, McKenzie was selected Colgate's Offensive MVP after leading the team with 477 kills (4.41 per game) and finishing second in kill attempts with 1,039, third in service aces with 26, third in digs with a total of 234 and paced the Raiders' blocking efforts with 132 total blocks (41 solo blocks, 91 block assists). In her sophomore campaign, McKenzie led the team in hitting percentage at .335 and finishing second in kills with 321. She was tabbed as the Patriot League's Rookie of the Year in 1993. In 2015, she was named to the Patriot League 25th Anniversary Volleyball Team.

Foyle played three seasons with the Raiders between 1995-97, leading Colgate to two NCAA tournament appearances. He earned All-America Second Team honors by the U.S. Basketball Writers Association and All-America Third Team by the Associated Press in 1997. Foyle finished his collegiate career as Colgate's second all-time leading scorer with 1,776 points and leading rebounder with 1,103. The two-time Patriot League Player of the Year was the NCAA all-time blocked shot leader with 492 at the time of his graduation. In his last season with the Raiders, Foyle was a finalist for the John R. Wooden and USBWA Player of the Year honors. He was the eighth pick overall in the 1997 NBA draft by the Golden State Warriors. Foyle was also a top-notch student-athlete, earning University-Division CoSIDA Academic All-America First Team honors in 1997. He was the 1996 Patriot League Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year. In 2002, Foyle became the fourth player in Colgate history to have his basketball number retired. In 2015, Foyle was named to the Patriot League 25th Anniversary Team in men's basketball.

Considered one of the most dominant softball players in Patriot League history, Donaldson was a four-time All-Patriot League First Team selection and earned the 2004 Player of the Year honor after leading the Raiders to a program-record 34 wins. Donaldson also landed All-Region First Team honors in 2004 and was recognized on the Second Team three times (2002, 2003, 2005), the only player in program history to earn four All-Region accolades. She remains Colgate’s all-time leader in home runs (39) and stands in the top five in program history in nearly every offensive category. Donaldson ranks second in batting average (.386), third in runs (120), third in hits (202), third in RBIs (126), fifth in doubles (34), and second in total bases (359). She was named the Patriot League Rookie of the Year in 2002 after belting 12 home runs as a freshman. In 2003, Colgate captured the Patriot League tournament title behind Donaldson’s .390 batting average, nine home runs and 33 RBIs. In 2015, Donaldson was named to the Patriot League’s 25th Anniversary Softball Team. 

A three time All-Patriot League section, Denenga finished her career in the Maroon and White with 65 games played, having only missed three games in four seasons. She posted career highs in every offensive category during a standout senior campaign in which she was named All-Patriot League First Team with 22 points on nine goals and four assists. Denenga ranked inside the top 10 in the Patriot League in six different offensive categories to land a spot on the league’s Outstanding Midfielders list. Originally from Harare, Zimbabwe, Denenga ranks No. 14 in program history in points (58) and goals (24). Strong off the field as well, she was a four-time selection in the National Field Hockey Coaches Association (NFHCA) Division I National Academic Squad. 

Butler enjoyed a spectacular four-year career for the Raiders from 2012-2016. She played in 104 games and recorded seven double-doubles. As a senior, the shooting guard out of Chicago was named team captain and started 13 games before suffering a season-ending injury. She was the repeat winner of the team’s Sparks Hustle Award after leading the team per game in rebounds (8.2) and assists (4.5). She picked off a career-best 15 rebounds against Holy Cross and finished just 43 shy of joining Colgate’s career top 10. During her junior season, Butler set a Colgate program record and ranked second in the Patriot League with 57 steals. She also topped the Raiders in field goal percentage (43.6%). In September of 2016, Butler became one of 23 individuals accepted to the Victory Scholar Program. The Patriot League nominated Butler for the program and she was accepted. The program allows U.S. postgraduates the chance to continue playing the sport they love while teaching the game to local youth and attending one of the world's most prestigious universities.

A three-time Patriot League and Raider Academic Honor Roll selection, Patterson was n amed team captain of the Colgate men’s lacrosse program during his senior season in 2017. The Millstone, New Jersey, native wrapped up his career with 29 ground balls and 10 caused turnovers in 34 appearances including 27 starts. Patterson started the last 25 games in which he appeared as a key member of the Raider defense. Patterson posted a career-high three ground balls against both Boston University and Cornell and tallied multiple ground balls against Marist, Hobart, and Siena. During his senior season, Patterson started every game for the Raiders. 

Omorogbe helped lead Colgate Men’s Soccer to unprecedented territory as the first program in Patriot League history to win three consecutive tournament championships. During Omorogbe’s time with the Maroon and White, Colgate won three league championships, earned its first-ever NCAA tournament victories and advanced to its first-ever NCAA Sweet 16. He wrapped up his career with 21 points on seven goals and seven assists. Four of his goals were game-winners. Omorogbe was a three-time selection on the Patriot League and Raider Academic Honor Rolls. After graduation, the economics major quickly grew into an entrepreneur, creating the clothing line NaSo to support individuals within Nigeria and communities throughout the African continent. Through proceeds from NaSo, in 2019 Omorogbe was able to help build a new school for hundreds of children in Nigeria and provide the necessary resources for a quality education.