Softball 2026
Colgate Softball defied expectations by having a record-breaking season while playing with one of the smallest and youngest rosters in the country.

Young Softball Squad Pulls Off Record-Breaking Season

Underdog Mentality Helps Raiders Finish Near Top of Conference

By Rodrigo Santiago

When the 2026 softball season kicked off in Jacksonville, Fla., on Feb. 6, no one knew what to expect from the Raiders.

Preseason rankings had placed Colgate to finish fifth of seven teams in the Patriot League. And with one of the smallest—and youngest—rosters in the country, the Raiders had the elements for a tough season.

But every now and then, funny things happen in sports. Things that few could have predicted, and that’s precisely how it unfolded for Colgate.

The team went on to finish second in the conference, and came within two victories of winning the league. They hit home runs at an eye-popping rate, enough to enter the national rankings in a few offensive categories.

They had one of the best hitters in the conference in junior Nora Megenity, plus the top rookie in the Patriot League, Marina Taveras.

But what really set the 2026 Raiders apart from any team in Colgate Softball history was the laundry list of records that were shattered.

In all, 17 records were broken, including those in every offensive category. 

Some milestones were achieved quickly — like the home run record, which was set at the start of conference play in late March.

And they did it with a roster of 15, half of them first-years while playing a grueling schedule that required traveling to warmer climates each week for the first month-and-a-half of the season.

“This was a special season,” said head coach Marissa Lamison-Myers. “For us, there were a ton of ups and downs. That’s what you expect when you have such a young roster. We did it with 12 hitters, which is very difficult to do.

“When you consider the miles we put on our bodies, the hotel stays, to continue to play as competitively as we did until May, it was truly impressive,” she said. “All the credit goes to the players and the team.”

From the first series of the season, the Raiders were out to prove they were better than preseason predictions.  

“They really bought into this underdog-type mentality,” Lamison-Myers said. “They thought, ‘Nobody thinks we deserve this. Nobody thinks we’re as good as we are.’”


The team marched forward with seven first-years, two seniors, and one junior. The sophomores took on more leadership roles while still learning Division I competition themselves.

The team had three full-time pitchers, and a utility hitter with pitching experience was asked to help out.

Meanwhile, the first-years were thrown into new roles, playing every game while the team navigated through the season with a paper-thin bench.

Nora Megenity softball 2026
Junior outfielder Nora Megenity was a constant force for the Raiders, and went on to set five program records.

But the Raiders made it work thanks to their enthusiasm and determination, and camaraderie that reshaped the atmosphere in the locker room. Bonds were formed. Game in and game out, student-athletes were having fun.

Plus, there was wall-to-wall talent, and as the season progressed, student-athletes developed on the fly. They also thrived.

“We had a lot of great moments — a lot of teachable moments,” Lamison-Myers said. “I couldn’t be more proud of the group.”

The team clubbed 88 home runs, a single-season record. Other milestones include hitting 88 doubles, driving in 295 RBIs, scoring 306 runs, and hitting seven long balls in one game, which they did on March 21 against Lehigh.

One reason for the offensive barrage was the work of assistant coaches Matt Nandin and Adrienne Nardone, Lamison-Myers said.

“They did a fantastic job with our offense, making adjustments during the fall and coming up with our offensive plan in the spring,” she said. “Our players sticking to it and buying into our offensive plan was huge.”

The team also saw contributions throughout the lineup, with several players having breakout seasons.

Megenity was a force at the plate. She set program records for hits (75), runs scored (54), home runs (22), total bases (153), and at-bats (188).

Taveras cracked a home run in her first at-bat as a Raider and didn’t slow down from there. She set five records of her own while on her way toward becoming Patriot League Rookie of the Year.

In addition, if there was an award for the second best rookie of the conference, Kayla Martin, who was the only first-year selected to the All-Patriot League First Team, would have received serious consideration. The infielder was a three-time conference rookie of the week, and was named player of the week once.

Sophomore catcher Lily Haluska led the team with a single-season record 54 RBIs, and was one of four hitters on the team to bat at least .300 (Megenity, Taveras, and Martin being the others). 

The team’s offensive prowess and record-breaking season were beyond what Colgate coaches had expected going into the spring.

But two records that stood out to Lamison-Myers were those in the home run and doubles categories. 

“Both of those are a testament to the work of our players and their talent,” she said. “A lot of those doubles were manufactured because of good, aggressive baserunning.”


There were a few crucial moments throughout the season that spoke volumes about the resilience and tenacity of the team.

For example, Colgate began conference play with a three-game sweep at Lehigh. But what really caught the attention of the coaches was how the Raiders did it.

For example, Colgate began conference play with a three-game sweep at Lehigh. But what really caught the attention of the coaches was how the Raiders did it.

All three games were close. The Mountain Hawks had opportunities to jump ahead, but the Raiders refused to relinquish the lead in each game.

“In years past, when we had close games, we seemed to panic and crumble,” Lamison-Myers said. “We would never come out on top. But in those three games, when they got close, the team didn’t flinch. They buckled down and we were able to win.

“When Matt Nandin and I saw that, when we saw the results of those three games, that’s when we knew we had something going. We weren’t sure what, but there was something there that was different from all the other teams we coached here.” 

Marina Taveras softball 2026
Infielder Marina Taveras was named Patriot League Rookie of the Year after a stellar season with the Raiders.

Another critical moment came a few weeks later, on April 4 when Colgate defeated Army 4-3 in the 10th inning. First-year Tealla Rivera was the hero when she hit a walk-off home run.

“That win gave us confidence,” Laminson-Myers said. “It made us think, ‘We are legit contenders. This is within reach.’”

Colgate reached the title game for the first time since 2011. They finished the season at 29-26, falling to Boston University in the championship.

But the experience of playing in the big game was invaluable.

“That experience that we got, especially for our first-years and sophomores, sets us up for the next two to three years,” Lamison-Myers said.

“Standing there, waiting for the championship game to start, you can see that their hearts were pounding out of their chests,” Lamison-Myers said. 

“They were excited and proud to reach the title game. It validated a lot of the hard work they put in. Now, the next time they play in that game, the focus will be on executing our plan for that game, not so much the congratulations of achieving it.”

The team will re-group in the first week of September to begin fall training. One of the areas the Raiders will focus on is defense. Despite a memorable 2026 season filled with highlights, the team made errors that proved costly.

“The defensive side of the ball is one area where we have to improve the most,” Lamison-Myers said. “If you ask me what held us back, it was our defense. We need to improve how we take care of the ball.”

Nine incoming student-athletes will join the squad next fall, including a few pitchers and several hitters who will add speed to the lineup. 

They will also bring much-needed depth.

“The response we got from the incoming class as we were going through the spring season was, ‘We are so excited,’” Lamison-Myers said. “Our upperclassmen have already texted them, getting them ready. We tell them, ‘You just have to be there.’ Our incoming players have to be there and feel what this environment is like. The softball environment at Colgate has never been better.” 


SEASON HIGHLIGHTS

Overall Record: 29-26, 13-5 PL

  • 29 wins are the most since going 34-17 in 2004
  • The 13 Patriot League wins are also the program's most since going 14-9 in 2021
  • Colgate finished as the No. 2 seed for the Patriot League tournament – its highest seed since earning the top spot and regular-season title in 2011.

Program Records

  • Nora Megenity, 75 hits, single-season record
  • Nora Megenity, 54 runs scored, single-season record
  • Nora Megenity, 22 home runs, single-season record
  • Nora Megenity, 153 total bases, single-season record
  • Nora Megenity, 188 at-bats, single-season record
  • Lily Haluska, 54 RBIs, single-season record
  • Marina Taveras, 62 hits, first-year single-season record
  • Marina Taveras, 46 RBIs, first-year single-season record
  • Marina Taveras, 49 runs, first-year single-season record
  • Marina Taveras, 14 home runs, first-year single-season record
  • Marina Taveras, 116 total bases, first-year single-season record
  • 88 home runs, single-season record
  • 306 runs scored, single-season team record
  • 295 RBIs, single-season team record
  • 86 doubles, single-season team record
  • 7 home runs vs Lehigh (3/21/26), single-game team record
  • 6 doubles vs UMES (3/17/26), single-game team record

Offense

  • .277 batting average, best in a season since 2021 (.283)
  • Ranked 16th nationally in home runs (88) and 15th in home runs per game (1.59)

Pitching/Defense

  • 29 wins, most since 2004 (34)
  • Kelcie McGraw, 14 wins, most by a Colgate pitcher since Kelsey Nordstrom's in 2007 (17)
  • 7 saves, most since 2022 (7)

All-League Honorees

  • 5 All-Patriot League awards, most since 2011 (6)
  • Marina Taveras, Patriot League Rookie of the Year, third Colgate player in last five years

Support Colgate Athletics
The loyal and collective generosity of alumni, families, and friends like you helps provide a first-class Division I experience. Support student-athletes like those on the softball team by making a gift to the Colgate Athletics Fund or team(s) of your choice, here.