In the old gym building, basketball practices were conducted on a small court. Some programs, like winter track, had no opportunities for indoor practice. The building did not contain the facilities for aquatic sports.
“In fact, on special occasions, it has been almost impossible to find a method by which all those wishing admission can be taken care of. Our athletic teams also have been greatly handicapped due to the lack of space and equipment,” wrote the staff of the 1927 yearbook.
The Colgate Alumni Corporation launched a massive fund-raising effort to build the $400,000 Huntington Gymnasium. Alumnus and undergraduates were required to help raise money. Gifts arrived in all amounts, with some people showing their love for Colgate by making huge sacrifices to donate.
One alumnus, who suffered from paralysis, relied on a $75 check from the government. The alumnus donated that payment to help build Huntington.
Meanwhile, as designs for the new building were being conceived, Colgate officials visited gymnasiums around the country, including those in Cornell, Dartmouth, Yale, and Syracuse. Their research allowed architects to include the best features of modern gymnasiums in their plans.
Huntington Gymnasium was designed as a three-story structure, made of natural gray limestone, with a court suitable for basketball, a swimming pool, new locker rooms, and sufficient space to accommodate all its programs. It also included offices and storage rooms.
On the day of the groundbreaking, Colgate President George B. Cutten and George Cobb ’94, the Alumni Corporation president, were dressed in full academic regalia as they handled the plough to make the first cut in the soil. The task required the help of 119 seniors who were clad in caps and gowns.
Hundreds of alumni were present for the ceremony, and cheered as they watched.
It took less than two years for Huntington Gymnasium to be built. The arrival of a new facility came at an impeccable time. A few months before the grand opening, the old gymnasium was destroyed in a fire.
A key contribution to the construction came from James C. Colgate ’84, who donated the money to complete the swimming pool after it was discovered that the budget would fall short of covering the expense.
Honoring the building after Ellery C. Huntington was an obvious choice. In his 25 years at Colgate, he had won the respect and love of every student who came under his influence. Known as “Doc” Huntington, he not only healed wounds but helped students overcome whatever difficulties they encountered.
In the 1926 April-May edition of Colgate Magazine, “Doc” Huntington wrote an article to provide an update on the construction, which was near completion.
“It stands as a magnificent monument to the sacrifice of all who have and all who will through the Alumni Fund, give of their generosity,” he wrote. “This building will provide for future generations of Colgate men that necessary development of body which is such an essential part of the development of mind.”